by TheJusticeofthePeace @ 25. Nov. 2010. – 14:13:44
The Magistracy is trumpeted as
being a uniquely English institution allowing local justice to be dispensed by
local people. With certain caveats I would agree. The Scottish and Irish
versions are not quite the same. Individual benches must follow strict
guidelines in performing some duties and are most locally idiosyncratic in
others. Individual benches control their own rota, ideally placing mixed sex
and ethnic benches where possible. Rota systems are very variable with some
benches following outdated local procedures that should have gone out with
ladies` compulsory hats and cigarette holders de rigueur in the retiring room
whilst others perform this vital function using common sense and the latest
soft ware.
One vital aspect of bench representation is the Bench Training and Development Committee. This can be appointed internally or have individuals elected annually. But here`s the b u t………….if an elective committee only those attending the annual election meeting can vote. No postal or proxy voting is allowed. At my bench about one third of members turn up………of course not always the same third. To allow change in the voting system or to allow benches to alter their own voting procedures government would have to table a statutory instrument. Perhaps there is an organisation of magistrates which might consider lobbying for this extension of democracy or is that akin to asking the pot to call the kettle black?
One vital aspect of bench representation is the Bench Training and Development Committee. This can be appointed internally or have individuals elected annually. But here`s the b u t………….if an elective committee only those attending the annual election meeting can vote. No postal or proxy voting is allowed. At my bench about one third of members turn up………of course not always the same third. To allow change in the voting system or to allow benches to alter their own voting procedures government would have to table a statutory instrument. Perhaps there is an organisation of magistrates which might consider lobbying for this extension of democracy or is that akin to asking the pot to call the kettle black?
No comments:
Post a Comment